How a silly prompt saved my story

I used to think writing prompts were just for new writers. Then I hit a wall with my fantasy novel and tried a prompt about a talking cat. It turned into a subplot that tied everything together. Now I'm a believer, but I'm still puzzled why some prompts click and others don't.

4 comments

4 Comments

river_dixon6mo ago

Honestly my track record with prompts is like a comedy of errors. Spent a whole week trying to force a story about a sentient refrigerator, which was just terrible. But then a simple one like "a key that doesn't fit any lock" somehow spiraled into my best chapter. It's totally random why some work and others crash and burn. Guess we just have to mine through the silliness for those weird gems.

gibson.morgan5mo ago

Lmao that fridge idea is killing me. It's like your brain gets stuck on the dumbest possible track and just will not let go. The worst part is you can feel it's bad the whole time but you keep digging anyway. Then some random throwaway thought actually works and you're just left confused. The creative process is just organized chaos at this point.

sean8546mo ago

Wait, you actually spent a whole week on a sentient refrigerator idea? That is completely bonkers to me. I can see why some prompts crash and burn so hard. But then a simple thing like a key without a lock turns into gold, it's weird how that works. Our minds must just grab onto random stuff when we're desperate. Maybe all the bad tries just make room for the one good idea to break through.

reese_hayes716mo ago

Totally! It's funny how those terrible ideas can come back around later in a weird way too. Maybe that sentient fridge flops hard now, but in six months you'll need a weird side character and suddenly that awful concept becomes perfect. Our brains are just throwing everything at the wall on a crazy delay! The bad tries aren't just empty space, they're like compost for the good stuff that finally grows.