Debate: Should doctors push HRT harder for perimenopause or let us figure it out?

I was at my yearly checkup in Austin last month and my doctor glossed over my mood swings and brain fog, just said 'it's normal.' But my friend in Dallas got her HRT prescribed right away at 45 and says she feels like a new person. On one hand, maybe jumping into hormones too fast messes with your natural balance. On the other, why suffer through years of anxiety and hot flashes when there's a fix? What's your take - should providers be more proactive or let patients decide?

3 comments

3 Comments

vera19518d ago

Yeah I just read this piece in the New York Times about how a lot of women's symptoms get brushed off as 'just getting older' when really it's a hormone crash happening way earlier than expected. My cousin in Portland was told the same thing for two years before she finally found a doctor who took her seriously and got her on a low dose patch. She said the brain fog lifted within a month, it was wild. But I've also seen a friend try HRT and it made her anxiety worse at first, so it's not a magic fix for everyone. I guess I lean toward doctors being more upfront about it as an option, like here's the info and the risks, now you decide. That way you're not just left in the dark wondering if your hot flashes and mood swings are just your new normal or something you could actually do something about.

drewr1517d ago

My aunt went through the same thing, dismissed for two years before finding a doctor who actually listened. I used to think HRT was overhyped until she told me how much better she felt after starting a patch. Your point about giving people the full picture so they can decide for themselves makes a lot of sense.

margaretramirez17d ago

Gotta disagree a bit here @vera195. I get that some women need HRT and it works great for them, but I think we're jumping too fast into medicating a natural transition. My sister tried it after reading all the same articles and ended up with blood clots that landed her in the ER. Not saying doctors should ignore us completely, but pushing it harder means more women might think it's the only fix when lifestyle changes like diet and exercise helped me way more with my hot flashes. Doctors should tell you it's an option, sure, but let the patient decide after hearing the full picture, not just the success stories.

-1